Skip to content

Pecan & Peanut Butter Pie Recipes


Free Shipping on all orders $49+ at Peets.com

Pecan is the fourth most popular pie in the United States. It’s popularity is predominant in the South where most of our pecans are grown. Georgia produces the most pecans in the U.S. with an average yearly crop of 100 million pounds. Georgia is often consider the “Triple P” state. It’s main agricultural crops are peanuts, pecans, and peaches.

Pecan pies were first made with molasses, cane syrup, and other dark syrups, long before corn syrup was developed. The introduction of Karo corn syrup played a major role in popularizing pecan pie nationwide. The company promoted pecan pie as a new use for corn syrup in the 1930s, claiming the recipe came from the wife of one of its sales executives. After the introduction of corn syrup, pecan pie started appearing widely in American cookbooks.

The most popular types of pecan pies include chocolate pecan pie, bourbon pecan pie, caramel pecan pie, peanut butter pecan pie. It’s not surprising that peanut butter is so popular. Like pecans, in the U.S. peanuts are grown primarily in the South where the growing seasons is more conducive to year-round production.

Peanut butter pies are so popular because combine creamy, salty‑sweet peanut butter with a cool, fluffy texture and a crunchy crust. This creates a dessert that hits every pleasure point at once. The flavor is nostalgic, the texture is comforting, and the balance of richness and lightness makes each bite feel indulgent without being heavy. A peanut butter cream pie satisfies your taste buds and ultimately leaves you craving more.

Other Recipes You Might Like

Pecan Cheesecake Pie

Quick & Easy Pecan Cheesecake Pie Recipe – Creamy Holiday Dessert

Pecan is by far the most popular pie in the South. In other areas it’s hardly ever made. Cheesecake is the most popular refrigerated dessert…
Easy Peach Raspberry Pie

Easy Peach Raspberry Pie Recipe – Fresh, Juicy Summer Dessert

This unique combination of peaches and raspberries is neither a Southern nor a Northern traditional recipe. Peach pie is predominant in the South while raspberries…
Quick and Easy Apricot Pie

Quick & Easy Apricot Pie Recipe with Canned Filling

This quick & easy apricot pie recipe uses canned apricot pie filling to save time without sacrificing quality and flavor. It can be prepared in…
Fluffy Banana Cream Pie

Fluffy Banana Cream Pie Recipe – Easy No-Bake Creamy Dessert

This is not your typical banana cream pie. One slice and you’ll feel like you’ve eaten an entire meal. The mousse-like texture and real banana…
Quick and Easy Pecan Pie

Quick & Easy Pecan Pie Recipe (Classic Southern Favorite)

Pecan pies aren’t as difficult to make as some cooks want you to think! I once ate at a local diner in the South that…
Chocolate Cranberry Chess Pie

Chocolate Cranberry Chess Pie Recipe – Rich, Fudgy & Tart Southern Pie

This recipe combines the tart flavor of cranberries with rich, sweet chocolate, custard, and cornmeal for a unique dessert that’s an uncommon twist on the…

Pie Tips, How To’s & Baking News

Homemade Flaky Vegan Pie Crust

Flaky Vegan Pie Crust Recipe (Easy, Buttery & Dairy-Free)

Most vegan pie crust recipes use vegetable shortening or an alternative ingredient to replace the butter. The crust isn’t flaky and often has the same…
Graham Cracker Pie Crust

Super Easy Graham Cracker Pie Crust Recipe (Regular or Gluten-Free)

If you’ve looked at any of my other specialty crust recipes you know I’m a stickler when it comes to perfection. I’ve looked at countless…
Baking With Maple

Making Pies With Maple: Best Maple Syrup Grades, Baking Tips & Pie Recipes

I live in New England and have tapped my own maple trees many times. Just like peaches and pecans are ingrained in Southern tradition and…
Wild Blueberries

Key Tips For Making Blueberry Pie

All blueberries are not the same. If you run across a recipe that claims you can don’t need to modify the ingredients for fresh versus…
Photo Credit: Instacart

Instacart Reveals America’s Favorite Pies

In celebration of Pi Day on March 14 (3/14)—a food holiday we all savor for making math just a little sweeter—Instacart takes a delicious look…
Assorted Types of Apples

Types of Apples For Apple Pies

Many bakers swear that crisp apples make the best pies. They claim that soft apples make the pie too mushy. They prefer sweet, crisp apples…

Peet's Coffee New Packaging
Free Shipping on all orders $49+ at Peets.com